| YEAR | CHAMPION | FIRST HALF | SECOND HALF |
| 1922 | Brooklyn Dodgers | ||
| 1923 | Paterson Legionaries | Elizabeth | Paterson Legionaries |
| 1924 | Brooklyn Visitations | Brooklyn Visitations | Brooklyn Visitations |
| 1925 | Brooklyn Visitations | Passaic/Kingston Colonials | Brooklyn Visitations |
| 1926 | Greenspoint Knights of St. Anthony | Yonkers Indians | Greenspoint Knights of St. Anthony |
| 1927 | Brooklyn Visitations | Brooklyn Visitations | Paterson Crescents |
| 1928 | Kingston Colonials | ||
| 1932 | Brooklyn Visitations | ||
| 1933 | Brooklyn Jewels | Brooklyn Jewels | Union City Reds |